The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Author: Phurster
Date: 2010-11-01 10:05

Thanks for your opinion Greg. I love the sound of Wurlitzers (or at least German players) when they play Beethoven but to my ear they sound nothing like the 'original instrument' recordings i have.

You make a good point about pedigree but I feel the many acoustical changes made over a number of years have made the modern instrument a totally different beast.

Yes the player is the most important aspect when considering sound. Pascual Moragues is an interesting example. I read about his admiration for Karl Leister (someone I admire also). I read about how he tries to emulate Karl's sound. With this in mind I bought a recording of his wind quintet. Well, the smoothness of technique was similar in both players but to me they sounded very different. Moragues plays with a light, smooth vibrato and the colour of the sound is totally different to Karl Leister's. Phrasing could perhaps be considered similar.

I suppose this shows how subjective our perceptions are. Hope you don't mind the different perspective.

Chris Ondaatje.

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Simon Aldrich

2010-10-30 19:46

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

donald

2010-10-30 19:53

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Chris P

2010-10-30 20:49

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Simon Aldrich

2010-10-30 21:55

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Chris P

2010-10-30 22:39

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Ed Palanker

2010-10-31 15:27

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Simon Aldrich

2010-10-31 16:26

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Tony Pay

2010-10-31 16:37

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Simon Aldrich

2010-10-31 17:31

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

John Peacock

2010-10-31 18:16

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Ed Palanker

2010-10-31 18:57

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Tony Pay

2010-10-31 19:12

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Simon Aldrich

2010-10-31 19:18

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Simon Aldrich

2010-10-31 19:42

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Gregory Smith

2010-10-31 21:21

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Chris P

2010-10-31 23:19

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Ed Palanker

2010-11-01 01:05

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Gregory Smith

2010-11-01 01:59

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Ed Palanker

2010-11-01 03:47

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Phurster

2010-11-01 07:27

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Gregory Smith

2010-11-01 08:37

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Phurster

2010-11-01 10:05

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Gregory Smith

2010-11-01 11:05

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Tony Pay

2010-11-01 11:19

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Tony Pay

2010-11-01 12:16

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Mark Charette

2010-11-01 13:02

Re: Strauss Oboe Concerto cl part transposed at BSO?

Tony Pay

2010-11-01 14:13

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.