The Oboe BBoard

The Oboe BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune?

Author: JRC
Date: 2015-02-03 07:08

I think you are asking or pondering about what the "right" pitch is. I do not believe there is a simple answer to this dilemma. The right pitch measured by a tuner (or in equal temperament system of tuning) is a safe way to do things. If everyone does this in an ensemble, the harmony and melody do not necessarily feel natural (or warm) but it is a sure way to be clean and well defended way to do this thing. However, our perception are tuned naturally. We feel more comfortable to sing in a natural scale and feel warmer listening to harmonic progression with natural tuning pitches. As you can see that a well tuned piano is incapable of doing this. Like they say... a tone deaf can play a piano well but not oboe.

I am most sensitive to tuning when I practice long notes, which I start every practice session with. I noticed that I produce the same note in slightly different pitch in different key. It appears that I feel more comfortable in a little higher, a little lower, or at tuner exact pitches depending on the key I am in. The effect seems more pronounce when I play a slower schmaltzy phrase (an Irish folk theme for instance), especially in minor keys. I am sure this idea will not be compatible with atonal music, which is based on equal temperament system of scale.

Perhaps, your director is looking for that natural sound.

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

ohsuzan

2015-02-03 04:44

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

WoodwindOz

2015-02-03 05:12

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

mjfoboe

2015-02-03 05:36

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

WoodwindOz

2015-02-03 05:57

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

oboi

2015-02-03 06:27

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

JRC

2015-02-03 07:08

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

jhoyla

2015-02-04 11:09

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

mjfoboe

2015-02-05 02:35

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

Chris P

2015-02-04 14:51

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

oboi

2015-02-05 03:28

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

WoodwindOz

2015-02-05 05:38

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

cjwright

2015-02-05 13:02

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

mjfoboe

2015-02-05 21:57

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

jhoyla

2015-02-05 16:40

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

ohsuzan

2015-02-06 12:02

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

ptarmiganfeather

2015-02-06 12:49

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

WoodwindOz

2015-02-06 18:05

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

oboi

2015-02-07 00:21

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

ohsuzan

2015-02-07 03:56

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

Scandinavian

2015-02-18 21:13

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

cjwright

2015-02-19 07:05

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

jhoyla

2015-02-19 16:26

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

mjfoboe

2015-02-19 17:44

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

Scandinavian

2015-02-19 21:44

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

JRC

2015-02-20 02:03

Re: Intonation -- What Constitues Being In Tune? new

Jeltsin

2015-02-20 12:22

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.