The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: "Voicing" is a crock

Author: Tony Pay ★2017
Date: 2010-03-05 13:08

I wrote:

>> I find:

http://test.woodwind.org/Databases/Klarinet/1998/12/000764.txt

...also relevant.>>

I think this article has been misunderstood. The point is that the 'hippopotamus' device is very different from a human player. You cannot deduce anything about what WE 'should' do from it.

Our mouths have a volume more than three orders of magnitude smaller. Indeed, since humans vary considerably in their physical makeup, it lends support to the idea that different players 'should' adopt different strategies.

I find myself fortunately free from the constraints laboured under by dogmatic, lay-down-the-law legendary-teacher-worshippers.

I try to think intelligently about what I do, and I listen to what (some) other people say; but ultimately, I do what works.

And, 'voicing' is not a crock. See, also:

http://test.woodwind.org/Databases/Klarinet/2003/10/000046.txt

Tony

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

"Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-04 19:12

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

weberfan

2010-03-04 19:18

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-04 19:31

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

TPeterson

2010-03-04 19:39

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Alseg

2010-03-04 20:17

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

am0032

2010-03-04 19:48

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Clarimeister

2010-03-04 20:17

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

mrn

2010-03-04 20:53

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Bartmann

2010-03-04 21:22

Re: new

Barry Vincent

2010-03-04 21:49

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

tictactux

2010-03-04 22:30

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

skygardener

2010-03-05 01:38

Re: new

Phurster

2010-03-05 06:05

Re: new

Tony Pay

2010-03-05 09:49

Re: "Voicing" is a crock

Tony Pay

2010-03-05 13:08

Re: new

Mark Charette

2010-03-05 13:49

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Phurster

2010-03-05 10:57

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

MartyMagnini

2010-03-05 11:47

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-05 11:51

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-05 12:11

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

MartyMagnini

2010-03-05 13:15

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Ed

2010-03-05 12:28

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Lelia Loban

2010-03-05 13:37

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

NBeaty

2010-03-05 14:21

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

mrn

2010-03-05 15:08

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

NBeaty

2010-03-05 15:45

Re: new

Ed Palanker

2010-03-05 16:21

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Arnoldstang

2010-03-05 18:04

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Alseg

2010-03-05 18:24

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

TPeterson

2010-03-05 19:15

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Tony Pay

2010-03-05 21:52

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

mrn

2010-03-05 20:13

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

sdr

2010-03-05 20:58

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Arnoldstang

2010-03-05 21:52

Re: new

kimber

2010-03-05 21:58

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-06 00:02

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Phurster

2010-03-06 00:18

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

A Brady

2010-03-06 02:00

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-06 02:35

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Ed Palanker

2010-03-06 03:19

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

skygardener

2010-03-06 03:23

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-06 04:35

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

skygardener

2010-03-06 08:29

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Paul Aviles

2010-03-06 14:40

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

skygardener

2010-03-06 15:28

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

mrn

2010-03-06 16:18

Re: new

donald

2010-03-06 21:38

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Phurster

2010-03-06 22:50

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Tony Pay

2010-03-07 07:34

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Lelia Loban

2010-03-07 11:44

Re: "Voicing" is a crock new

Arnoldstang

2010-03-08 04:22

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.