 The Clarinet BBoard
|
Author: GenericClarinet129
Date: 2024-11-29 17:48
I have been using a Rovner Dark ligature for a decently long time. It holds the reed well, but the articulation and response are somewhat stuffy, and I need to completely reset the reed and ligature whenever I adjust the mouthpiece, so I am in the market for a new ligature. Please do not respond that I should not buy a ligature because they are unimportant, do not affect sound, etc. or that I should spend my money on other, more important things. I already have a good mouthpiece (Vandoren M30), a good clarinet (Uebel Reve), and take regular lessons, and I practice as much as I have time for. I use Legere European cut reeds. I thought I had narrowed it down to the Vandoren Optimum, but then I heard about a few other people that use Legere reeds for whom the Optimum did not function (it was an issue about the ligature not tightening enough, I believe). Does this problem really exist? I am also considering the BG Duo. Does anybody have any experience with that one; if so, how well does it work with Legere reeds? Are there any other ligatures that are similar to those that work especially well with Legeres? I am opposed to purchasing another Rovner, and I don't really have time to assemble a ligature out of string or velcro every time I take out my clarinet.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Slowoldman
Date: 2024-11-29 17:58
I found the Vandoren Optimum to be too slippery with Legere reeds. It kept coming off when I had to change clarinets.
Amateur musician, retired physician
Delaware Valley Wind Symphony, clarinet 1
Bucks County Symphony Orchestra, clarinet 2 (sub)
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Burt
Date: 2024-11-29 18:18
I use a Luyben ligature with M30 and Legere Euro 3.5.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: kdk
Date: 2024-11-29 18:38
GenericClarinet129 wrote:
> I have been using a Rovner Dark ligature for a decently long
> time. It holds the reed well, but the articulation and response
> are somewhat stuffy, and I need to completely reset the reed
> and ligature whenever I adjust the mouthpiece,
Can you tighten the Rovner more to have it hold in place more securely?
> I thought I had narrowed it down to the
> Vandoren Optimum, but then I heard about a few other people
> that use Legere reeds for whom the Optimum did not function (it
> was an issue about the ligature not tightening enough, I
> believe). Does this problem really exist?
This is a problem that, in my experience, tends to happen with some ligatures on specific mouthpieces made from narrower blanks. When I was experimenting with Legeres a few years ago, I used the same Bonade inverted ligature that I still use on cane reeds, but because the Legeres are thin compared to many cane reeds, especially thick-blank ones like V.12, V21 and 56 Rue Lepic, I had to put a mouthpiece patch on the back of the mouthpiece to give *it* more girth to spread the ligature a little. I do the same when I use Vandoren traditionals, which are also thin.
Vandoren mouthpieces in general are moderately large in girth compared to other mouthpieces I've tried. It may not be a problem with your M30.
I think I also used an Optimum lig with the Legeres, also with the rubber patch on the back of the mouthpiece. I still bounce back and forth between Bonade and Optimum, some days liking one better and other days preferring the other. They both work well.
Karl
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Ed
Date: 2024-11-29 20:06
I think the Luyben is a good choice to consider. They are good ligatures and relatively inexpensive. They also hold very well.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: NOLA Ken
Date: 2024-11-29 20:38
I also sometimes used a Luyben ligature on a VD M30 (Lyre) mouthpiece with the Legere Euro cut reeds. I have used Rovner Dark and Light ligs, but find the Luyben gives a cleaner sound and better articulation. But I also find that I often have to reset the reed if I adjust the mouthpiece, and sometimes the Luyben lig slips off when adjusting the mouthpiece.
Another recent find was a Syos 3D printed slip-fit ligature. The one I have is for my alto clarinet but they are available for Bb sopranos also. The design easily fits most mouthpieces. I find that it produces very nice sound and is very responsive with synthetic reeds. It sometimes requires adjusting the reed placement after adjusting the mouthpiece, but it is very much easier and quicker to adjust than ligatures with screws. Mountng the reed is a breeze compared to anything with a screw.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: RBlack
Date: 2024-11-29 21:14
For me, the BG duo has been the most secure ligature I’ve tried with legeres, so it works very well for switching between Bb/A without all falling apart.
These days the Ishimori Kodama 2 is my favorite in terms of how it plays, but it isn’t all that secure in comparison to others I’ve used.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Paul Aviles
Date: 2024-11-30 19:29
Sorry I'm late to this one. You already own one of the very best ligatures for Legere (or any reed)!
Take the Rovner dark and just flip it so that the screw is on the left side and the ligature tightens OVER the reed. You'll be amazed at what a difference this makes. Once convinced, just flip the rods so that it's back to having the screw on the right side.
Yes I agree that the Optimum (with the four dot plate) is also one of the best as well. However, with the thin (up and down thin that is) Legeres, I use the German mouthpiece sized Optimum.
https://www.thomannmusic.com/vandoren_optimum_ligature_bb_german_sp.htm
Of course I add a shim cut from a plastic ligature cap or pill bottle when the ligatures themselves are too big for the Legere combo.
............Paul Aviles
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Bob Barnhart ★2017
Date: 2024-11-30 23:20
Paul,
I agree with your suggestions about the Rovner Dark ligature. I have never been a real fan of this ligature as it always seemed to restrict the sound. Interestingly, I received a Rovner Dark with a 10K 3L that Clark Fobes sent me and it played much better. The difference was HIS had no stitches on the flaps around the pins, it was only glued.
As I'm always testing things, several months ago I tried the new Legere French Cut reeds as well as the current version of the European Cut reeds. As the Legeres are picky about ligatures I tried some experiments. One of which was to turn the Rovner Dark's screw around to use it in the "pins-on-the-reed" position. The ligature still worked fine with the Legeres and its performance for all reeds was vastly better: less resistance, better response, and a freer/rounder sound.
However, I got an even better result with the Rovner Star Series ligature in the "pins-on-reed" position. IMHO, I find this ligature to be superior to the Dark because of the much thinner fabric (and the lower price!).
I know this will sound heretical to those (like me) who agree with Bonade that pressing the reed against the mouthpiece along the spine of the bark should allow the reed to vibrate better, but I find that for both cane and synthetic reeds, using the Rovner Dark and Star Series ligatures in the "pins-on-reed" configuration seems to yield just as free/vibrant a sound, but also one that is rounder as well. After some thought, I believe that this is because the reed is held primarily by the edges, yet suffers no loss of vibrancy. Go figure.
Anyway, for me, the Rovner Star Series in the reversed position plays better for cane/synthetic reeds than any of the ligatures I have been able to afford.
Bob Barnhart
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Paul Aviles
Date: 2024-12-01 01:57
Absolutely! The Star is another great ligature.....used inverted from its intended orientation. I found this as I have been experimenting with turning as many "inverted" ligatures around as I can and saw someone in a community band playing one of these. Naturally I did a quick search of images and found this review which basically says the same thing:
https://www.saxnoir.com/site/?p=1537
I have one now and love it as well.
I am not sold on the idea of grip on the edges as much as an even hold on the reed itself. I have many different materials and weights of ligatures and the ONLY thing the best working models have in common is an even grip on the reed itself. It turns out you can't predict how well an inverted model holds because you are dealing with the cone shape of the mouthpiece as the aggravating factor. If you grab evenly across the TOP of the mouthpiece there is still no way to be sure what points along the reed are snug. Though I do have an inverted woven ligature by Vientos Bambu that works great, I feel that this is an accident of the shape being a good match for the angle of the cone that is created by the thin Legeres and the thin mouthpieces that I use.
...............Paul Aviles
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: GenericClarinet129
Date: 2024-12-01 06:49
Paul and Bob,
Thanks for your advice about the pins-on-the-reed position!
I tried un-inverting the Rovner Dark. Surprisingly, I did not notice a significant difference (although it was a little better than the default position). It might be something about my personal setup and embouchure, or I might just not be perceiving it. However, I did some experimenting, and I found that placing the ligature in the normal inverted position but extremely far down on the mouthpiece (so far down that part of it was on the barrel) while tightening it enough to still hold the reed securely makes a severely positive difference in the response and tone. This might not be effective for your specific setups, but it strangely seems to work wonders for me.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Paul Aviles
Date: 2024-12-01 16:02
You may try changing ligature position and tension which I find to be somewhat critical. For me, tightening the reed down too snug will choke off the sound. I'd recommend anything from "loose" to the point where the reed will move a bit from side to side with a modicum of effort. Also, the "bullet proof" ligature position that will work no matter what is lining the top edge with a point just a hair below the bottom edge of the window (which you can see through the reed). Experiment with this position through about 2mm below. If the reed is working great, you can go as low as the line of ligature and get even more resonance.
..............Paul Aviles
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
The Clarinet Pages
|
 |
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
