The Doublers BBoard  
     | 
 
    
    
Author: melearly  
Date:   2006-07-24 13:20 
 Improve Your Doubling 
Advanced Studies For Doublers 
Saxophone-Clarinet-Flute 
BY CHRIS VADALA 
http://www.dornpub.com/dornbook.html#Vadala 
 
Anyone tried it?  Any good? 
Looks like it could be a good idea
  
  | 
 
 
 | 
 
    
    Reply To Message
     
 | 
 
 
     | 
 
    
    
Author: Bret Pimentel  
Date:   2006-07-24 18:48 
 I have looked through it a few times, but never felt the need to buy it. The etudes are interesting and challenging (this is NOT a book for someone who is still struggling with basic fingering and tone production issues on any of the instruments). But I'm not sure why a serious doubler would buy this book instead of getting some of the tried-and-true etude books that flutists, clarinetists, and saxophonists use. Many of these are quite inexpensive and readily available. 
 
I guess I'm always suspicious of anything "for doublers"--I would rather study flute like a flutist than study flute like a saxophonist. 
 
Bret
  
  | 
 
 
 | 
 
    
    Reply To Message
     
 | 
 
 
     | 
 
    
    
Author: Merlin  
Date:   2006-07-25 19:52 
 I think the point with Vadala's book is the short amount of time given to change horns AND concepts.  
 
You can't get that just from regular etude books. 
 
I was playing a show book today, and I had to go from big band lead alto to legit flute, to a notated Dixie clarinet solo to picc in two pages. 
 
  
  | 
 
 
 | 
 
    
    Reply To Message
     
 | 
 
 
     | 
 
    
    
Author: Jaysne  
Date:   2006-08-09 03:06 
 I bought the book because I love to double.  I played out of it maybe twice.  I found it too overwhelming--the parts were too hard and weren't much fun to play. 
 
So I just went back to playing my etude and legit/jazz method books for sax, clarinet and flute, and have been fine ever since.
  
  | 
 
 
 | 
 
    
    Reply To Message
     
 | 
 
 
  
 | 
  The Clarinet Pages 
  | 
  |