Author: Norm L
Date: 2014-09-10 07:24
I recently bought a 920 from RDG at the IDRS convention to replace my Monnig 155 AM. The Monnig was actually a joy to play in most ways, but I had a persistent problem with a sharp high C and above. Interestingly, when I played it with a long scrape (American style) reed, that problem vanished. But I'm a huge European fan, and I'm too wedded to my short scrapes. I just needed to find the oboe that was right for me.
I tried most everything at IDRS, but I kept coming back to Marigaux. To me, they have this uniquely warm, deep purr that's so addictive. The altuglass was wonderful (but not so much the price tag!). The M2 seems to get most of the attention these days, but for two straight conventions, I preferred the old school sound and feel of the 901/920.
I played the three 920s at RDG many times over three days. Very consistent quality among them. I practically flipped a coin and just chose one. Then I compared it with my favorite wood 901 and plastic top 901. At most there was possibly a smidgen more edginess in the sound of the 920, but nothing I figured a little reed adjustment couldn't smooth out if necessary. Where it stood out for me was in responsiveness, particularly the low register. Very free and easy articulation.
In all, I found it very comparable to a grenadilla 901, and I loved the idea of not having to break it in or worry about cracks. A month later, and no regrets at all. No more intonation issues with my short scrape reeds. I play in heavy air conditioning, and I haven't had any sticking keys. Maybe a bit more prone to condensation in the side octave key, so I still warm it up the same as wood.
Having said all that - there was a Monnig AM at Ludwig Frank's booth that was an absolute dream to play. So tempting ...
Have fun testing, and let us know the results. In the end, I think the process comes down to a Harry Potter situation. We each have our own oboe/wand out there that's meant for us, so we can make our own style of magic.
Norm L
Post Edited (2014-09-10 07:30)
|
|
The Oboe BBoard
.jpg){kind=small}
