The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Author: Tony Pay ★2017
Date: 2013-11-10 18:06

>> After you commenting on the defectiveness of the Ricordi edition , I sat myself down and listened to these recordings whilst following this edition. What I hear seems to be identical or closely similar to what I have in the notation, especially the passages that we are discussing. >>

Don't worry about recordings. They're just what happened one Monday morning to some player or another;-)

Rather, the Ricordi edition is defective because it attempts to amplify what cannot be amplified: namely, Mozart's 'thin' notation. I'd say that Mozart wrote it that way because he knew that he couldn't improve it by making it 'thicker'.

Alamiro Giampieri effectively assumes that Mozart either didn't have a pen, or didn't know how to use it. If Mozart had thought that he could improve his music by writing in the nonsense that Giampieri writes, why would he not have done so? Mozart was nothing if not a working professional.

>> That is to say, I don't fret and stress out about the finer points of being precise in everything. It's probably why I'm now almost 70 years old and still going strong. >>

That I DO pay attention to these finer points is probably why I'm now almost 69 years old and still going strong.

But good luck to you.

Tony

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Staccatos Under A Slur?

Johnny Galaga

2013-11-09 01:19

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-09 02:08

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

davyd

2013-11-09 02:44

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

cigleris

2013-11-09 04:37

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-09 06:12

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Liquorice

2013-11-09 08:04

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Katrina

2013-11-09 12:39

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Lelia Loban

2013-11-09 15:26

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-09 15:55

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

MSK

2013-11-09 16:46

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

rmk54

2013-11-09 16:54

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-09 17:08

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Johnny Galaga

2013-11-09 19:14

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-09 20:12

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Liquorice

2013-11-09 20:14

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-09 21:07

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-09 21:40

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

kdk

2013-11-09 22:26

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-10 02:35

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

kdk

2013-11-10 03:55

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Andrez444

2013-11-10 08:29

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-10 12:17

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-10 15:43

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-10 17:48

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-10 18:06

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

kdk

2013-11-10 20:42

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Lelia Loban

2013-11-10 18:39

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 04:22

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

donald

2013-11-11 05:08

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

cigleris

2013-11-11 06:15

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 07:00

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 07:10

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 13:05

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Katrina

2013-11-11 14:42

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 16:42

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 18:02

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 20:25

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Arnoldstang

2013-11-11 21:33

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 21:41

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-11 23:03

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 23:54

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 17:46

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-12 10:22

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-12 13:54

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-12 13:55

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-12 14:13

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Tony Pay

2013-11-12 18:49

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.