Woodwind.OrgThe Clarinet BBoardThe C4 standard

 
  BBoard Equipment Study Resources Music General    
 
 New Topic  |  Go to Top  |  Go to Topic  |  Search  |  Help/Rules  |  Smileys/Notes  |  Log In   Previous Message  |  Next Message 
 Is clarinet inherently less passionate??
Author: theclarinetist 
Date:   2004-09-12 05:00

In my search for the perfect recording of the Brahms (so far I have Stoltzman, Wright, Leister, and Klocker... I have Shifrin and Soames on the way...), I'm starting to feel that the clarinet may be an instrument that is far less capable of passionate expression than my other two favorite instruments, piano and violin (both of which can be notoriously passionate). I've noticed this is many other pieces, but I'm thinking about the Brahms now, so that's what got me started.

Compared to some of the best of the piano/violin world, the best clarinet players seem to be lacking in passion in their playing. Two examples of very passionate players on piano and violin that come to mind are V. Horowitz and J. Heifetz. When listening to recordings by these two masters, I find their playing to be explosively passionate. Comparatively, many masters of the clarinet seem to play in a style that, while nearing technical perfection, is much less engaging. Some players (most notably Stoltzman) are capable of achieving passionate extremes, but often at the cost of tonely purity and control. Another good example (if you are curious what is motivating my questions) is the Prokofiev Sonata, Op. 94. When played on violin the piece sizzles with excitement (particularly the 2nd and 4th movements). When played on clarinet (by Larry Combs in my case), the piece is very well done (and quite passionate by clarinet standards), but still doesn't come close to the passion felt in the violin version.

This makes me wonder if the clarinet is physically more difficult to draw such passionate extremes from (because doing so is detrimental to tonal control, etc). Or is it just a matter of "clarinet philosophy" (or pedagogy, whatever you call it) that encourages more reserved style as opposed to the explosive vitality often found in the best of violin/piano music (for example, vibrato is a very effective expressive tool in violin and many other wind instruments, though it is traditionally frowned on for clarinets).

I'm certainly capable of appreciating the clarinet's better qualities (like it's voice-like fluidity and ability to create nuances in color and dynamics, and it's place as probably the most passionate woodwind instrument...) so I'm not making overly strict comparisons, and I realize that technical aspects of the instruments make it impossible to compare them exactly. However, I'd like to think that the power to play with such excitement and passion can (at least in theory) be achieved by any player no matter what instrument they play. Am I expecting too much, or do I need to redefine my concept of passionate playing when it comes to clarinets??



 Reply To Message  |  Avail. Forums  |  Flat View   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 

 Topics Author  Date
 Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  
theclarinetist 2004-09-12 05:00 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
morgan 2004-09-12 05:26 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
LeWhite 2004-09-12 05:38 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
buedsma 2004-09-12 07:07 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
allencole 2004-09-12 09:17 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Brenda Siewert 2004-09-12 14:24 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Markus Wenninger 2004-09-12 14:39 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Liquorice 2004-09-12 14:40 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Liquorice 2004-09-12 14:44 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
theclarinetist 2004-09-12 15:54 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
William 2004-09-12 16:12 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
EEBaum 2004-09-12 17:18 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
clarinetwife 2004-09-12 17:34 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
ken 2004-09-12 19:47 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
theclarinetist 2004-09-12 22:12 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
EEBaum 2004-09-12 22:39 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
ned 2004-09-13 03:52 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
EEBaum 2004-09-13 04:30 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
graham 2004-09-13 08:27 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
ned 2004-09-13 11:29 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Hank Lehrer 2004-09-13 11:30 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
William 2004-09-13 15:36 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
EEBaum 2004-09-13 15:40 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Rachel 2004-09-14 03:05 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
graham 2004-09-13 16:26 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Ken Shaw 2004-09-13 21:12 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Liquorice 2004-09-14 10:28 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Henry 2004-09-14 16:20 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
GBK 2004-09-14 16:44 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Henry 2004-09-14 20:41 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Gardini 2004-09-14 22:57 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Jack Kissinger 2004-09-14 23:36 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Tom J. 2004-09-15 00:03 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Ken Shaw 2004-09-15 14:27 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Markus Wenninger 2004-09-16 07:51 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
BobD 2004-09-16 21:57 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
TheSouthpaw 2004-09-16 22:24 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
Markus Wenninger 2004-09-17 06:15 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
BobD 2004-09-17 13:40 
 Re: Is clarinet inherently less passionate??  new
allencole 2004-09-18 22:11 


 Avail. Forums  |  Need a Login? Register Here 
 User Login
 User Name:
 Password:
 Remember my login:
   
 Forgot Your Password?
Enter your email address or user name below and a new password will be sent to the email address associated with your profile.
Search Woodwind.Org

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages
For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.

 
     Copyright © Woodwind.Org, Inc. All Rights Reserved    Privacy Policy    Contact charette@woodwind.org