Author: ohsuzan
Date: 2007-08-23 01:59
I really agree with what Max has written. I don't see the point of the "hybrid" oboe (resin top, wood bottom). I DO see the point of an all-resin oboe, and in fact, I own one, for use outdoors and in cold pits. But it is not the oboe that I would want to play for a critical listener.
You say your daughter's MARCHING band director is an oboist? Do you mean to say that they use oboes in her marching band? This would be very unusual, in my experience. But if so, then definitely, get a Fox resin or equivalent in another brand (Yamaha, etc.) -- or keep the plastic Selmer. Or get a cheapie at auction on you-know-where. It will just get trashed. I would just find it extremely unusual for anyone to march an oboe. DON'T let her use a Loree for marching band!!
But for her long-term development, your daughter is going to need a good, full-conservatory wood oboe. If your daughter's teacher is pushing a Loree, and if you respect the teacher, you might as well pay attention to her advice. Good used Lorees come on the market all the time, and there are numerous dealers out there who will help you with your choice.
One of the advertisers on this board might be able to help you in your search. http://www.hannahsoboes.com/ (I have not dealt with this source personally, but from the content of her website, would judge that she does know a thing or three about oboes.)
This is one area where you can be penny-wise and pound-foolish. Good oboes are expensive. But they are worth it, both in terms of aggravation avoided and results achieved.
Susan
|
|
The Oboe BBoard
.jpg){kind=small}
