The Clarinet BBoard
|
Author: Jimis4klar
Date: 2026-11-17 21:33
I wanted to share my frustration regarding Vandoren reed strengths, specifically the gap between #3 and #3.5. I play V12s, and #3 feels like it lacks the slight back pressure that I need, while #3.5 most of the time is more resistant than I like. While I've tried multiple times to adjust either strength to my liking, I feel I don't get what a stock #3+ would be without needing any adjustments.
Don't you have similar experiences with the reeds of your choice? I wouldn't like to switch from V12, because I believe the cane has more potential than other models. It feels quite unfair to me that Vandoren took care of the gap between #3.5 and #4 and not the #3 to #3.5, which I'm very positive most of players need way more.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Paul Aviles
Date: 2026-11-18 04:39
So I currently am in the middle of determining a direct relationship between your current dew point and the strength of your reed. If you live in an area where you have distinct seasons, and the dew point drops 20 degrees (Fahrenheit), your #3 reed should be the 3(+) that you are looking for. It would be great to find out if that works for you.
The explanation is long and circuitous sounding so I'd rather wait on that but will provide it if there is interest.
..............Paul Aviles
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: OldeSkool
Date: 2026-11-18 17:49
Selmer now makes 1/4 strength reeds (2.75, 3.25), but I have only found them on Sweetwater and Earspasm. FWIW, I moved from Ohio (low elevation, high humidity summers) to Colorado (high elevation, year round low humidity), and the 3.5 Vandoren reeds I used all my life felt like a popsicle stick. I had to drop down 1/2 strength to get them to work. Whether it’s the elevation/humidity change or a combination of both, I had to make a change. I found the Selmer 1/4 strength reeds helpful in this situation. The Selmer reeds play similar to the Vandorens.
Bill
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: SecondTry
Date: 2026-11-18 19:23
If you prefer a reed that offers more resistance, have you experimented with moving it slightly farther up the mouthpiece than your normal position, making adjustments in hairline increments? Similarly, have you tried shifting the reed slightly to the left or right to compensate for an imbalance in resistance between the two sides? If so, have you found these adjustments effective?
Personally, I rarely play a reed straight out of the box without making some adjustments. I regard the strength number printed on the box as little more than a starting point. Ideally, I want a reed that is initially just a bit stronger than what I ultimately prefer, giving me some room to work with it. I then use techniques from Ridenour's ATG method to bring the reed into playing condition and reduce its effective strength slightly.
Even assuming that Vandoren, whose reeds I use most often, cuts its profiles on carefully calibrated machines, using sharp knives and closely monitored quality-control procedures, as you probably know, the way an otherwise nearly perfectly cut reed plays can still be affected by natural inconsistencies in the cane itself. These variations can manifest themselves in both left-to-right balance and overall strength.
(Of course, it's entirely possible that you have a greater ability than I do to accurately assess the strength of a fresh reed.)
As you probably know, all reeds within a particular Vandoren model (V12, Blue Box/Traditional, 56 Rue Lepic, V21, etc.) are cut to the same profile specifications. Vandoren then uses an air-puff test to assess the deflection of each dry reed's tip. The test is conducted at a fixed distance and with a controlled puff of air, at a fixed point of the reed. The amount of deflection determines the reed's strength classification: the less the reed bends, the higher its assigned strength.
https://vandoren.fr/en/reeds-technical-elements/
I'm not sure I could suggest a better testing method that would be equally economical, but there are legitimate questions about how well this test replicates actual playing conditions. For example, it doesn't account for the reed being wet or for the rapid back-and-forth vibrations it experiences while being played.
https://chatgpt.com/s/t_6afdbaf079788191ac6f43d88406d73a
I wonder whether Vandoren has considered introducing an intermediate strength, such as 3.25, between its current 3 and 3.5 offerings. I don't know this to be the case, but perhaps the deflection measurements produced by its air-puff test don't produce a sufficient number of reeds falling within a midpoint, give or take, between those two strengths. Alternatively, perhaps the market simply hasn't demonstrated sufficient demand for the strength increment you wish.
It's also conceivable that the greater manufacturing consistency possible with synthetic reeds has influenced how manufacturers approach strength gradations in their cane-reed lines. Synthetic materials can be formulated to achieve more predictable characteristics than cane. I wouldn't rule out the possibility that this distinction plays some role in how manufacturers position their respective product lines, although I have no evidence that this has influenced Vandoren's decisions.
All of this leads me to a broader point, which is also something I'd encourage you to consider: I approach reeds much as a woodworker approaches commercially purchased lumber. Rather than assuming the material is ready to use as purchased, I consider it a raw material that may need further preparation. A woodworker might use jointer and planer toold to square and flatten a piece of wood respectfully; similarly, a clarinetist can (often but not always) use a reed knife or sandpaper to refine a reed until it responds and plays better to their liking.
One final thought: the ultimate goal is a reed that plays with perfect symmetry, not necessarily one that measures as perfectly symmetrical. Those two things are not always the same. A reed that looks or measures asymmetrical may, in fact, play remarkably evenly, while one that measures near perfectly symmetrical may not.
Good luck.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: kdk
Date: 2026-11-18 20:27
Jimis4klar wrote:
> I wanted to share my frustration regarding Vandoren reed
> strengths, specifically the gap between #3 and #3.5. I play
> V12s, and #3 feels like it lacks the slight back pressure that
> I need, while #3.5 most of the time is more resistant than I
> like. While I've tried multiple times to adjust either strength
> to my liking, I feel I don't get what a stock #3+ would be
> without needing any adjustments.
A couple of thoughts:
I don't think Vandoren packages a 3+ in any of its models, so there is nothing to switch to from a V12. However, both #3 Traditional and 56 Rue lepic models are in theory more resistant than #3 V.12. So, you may be able to learn to like either of those if you find their resistance more comfortable. The 56 Rue is a slightly different profile without V.12's straight "file" cut. Traditional, because it's a thinner blank, is cut more from the outer cane, nearer the bark, which tends to be stiffer than the more interior fibers in the thick blank - especially at the tip, which is deeper in the cane tube than the wood at the shoulder but still closer to the outer bark (hence, stiffer) than a thicker blank.
Karl
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Jimis4klar
Date: 2026-11-19 05:05
The thing is, the quality of the cane is much better on V12s. And I strongly believe that 3+ would be appealing to a lot more people than 3 1/2+ is, that's my point. Of course we'll play with what's available, but it's quite a pity not having the most ideal strength out of the box, without needing any adjustments.
Post Edited (2026-11-19 05:08)
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: donald
Date: 2026-11-19 07:42
I'd love a 3.25 V12, and have heard many times from players who find 3 too soft and 3.5 too hard. You are not alone.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Jimis4klar
Date: 2026-11-19 13:16
Yes, I'm very sure, this strength would appeal to a lot more players than 3 1/2+ does. It's also been a matter of quality of sound, not only ideal resistance. V12 3 1/2 is usually little darker than ideal and 3 more energetic and bright, with too excessive authority for classical, no matter the mouthpiece being played on.
Post Edited (2026-11-19 13:16)
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: kdk
Date: 2026-11-19 18:08
You're probably right. My current mouthpiece would be happier with a #3+ V.12 than a current #3.
But I'm curious what you base your opinion on that the quality of the cane is different between V.12 and the other Vandorens. The profile *is* different. And of course, the blank is thicker than a Traditional ("Blue Box") blank, which affects the stiffness. I'd think that, if the folks at Vandoren were going to use selected cane tubes for one model, it would be V21, which is premium-priced. They certainly aren't growing different cane for V.12 or any other model.
Karl
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
The Clarinet Pages
|
 |