The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Rose Etude 25 M 1-23

Author: kdk ★2017
Date: 2014-11-06 03:55

The first thing you need to take care of is that you're playing on a responsive reed. There's a lot of air in the sound that says you and your reed are fighting with each other. That causes a lot of inflexibility in your playing and will make it hard to phrase with any real shape. The reed is also causing squeaks.

I would avoid those swells in the long notes that are especially evident near the beginning. They don't contribute anything to the line - they tend in fact to draw attention away from it. You need to find where the phrases go and direct your sound to those places. For example, swelling the Eb in the first bar minimizes the importance of the D as the line descends. Then you swell again on the C in bar 2, so the perfectly balanced arc of that first phrase instead has two bumps in it that the composer (whoever he was) almost certainly didn't intend. Then the quarter notes at the end of bar 2, which only begin a new line that draws you all the way to the B-natural in bar 4, instead become the loudest notes in the phrase. You should think more about line throughout the etude. It isn't just a question of adding dynamic changes here and there (like the swells on the long notes) but one of knowing where you're going, where the tension builds and releases and making the sound do what the phrase asks.

I don't know what edition you're using. Some of the slurs you played aren't what's in the original (Carl Fischer) edition that I'm looking at. That doesn't matter so much unless your county adjudication has rules insisting on a specific edition. If there is a rule like that, make sure you have the right edition and follow the specific markings. Mine, for example, has definite p, f and mf markings that aren't coming out in your playing. And, to your specific question, I'd say yes, you should do the articulation as written but more clearly.

Part of the reason those two bars are difficult for you is that you're out of breath by then. One other thing you need to do with these etudes in general is decide where you're going to breathe and practice with those breaths. Although it's violin music (they can breathe while they play), this etude is fairly breath-friendly with half notes and even phrase-ending quarters that give you time to get breaths in. But that long passage of eighth notes right before your clip ends doesn't give you any of those places, so, if you can't do it without a breath, plan a place where you will interrupt the rhythm a little to get a real breath so that you don't have to break down and breath every couple of beats because you've run out of air. Find a place you can get to reliably that isn't too far from the half note after the rit (bar 22) and then practice the phrase the same way every time. Don't leave breaths to chance.

Good luck with it. Keep working.