The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Author: Barry Vincent
Date: 2013-11-11 16:42

Hi Tony, thanks for the two threads. I've read them and find them very interesting. I especially liked your explanation of your terms 'Thin notation' as in descriptive notation & 'Thick notation' as in prescriptive notation in the first thread. I was wondering what you meant by that.
In the second thread you had a very interesting opinion concerning the measures 81 through to 84 in the Concerto whereas the pulse of 81 is in 4. Then the pulse progresses to 2 in measure 82. And in measure 83 the pulse is in 1.
I agree with that opinion.
In both my editions (Boosey & Hawkes/Frederick Thurston) & (Ricordi/Alamiro Giampieri), measure 83 has a slur on the first two semiquavers and a second slur on the 9th & 10th semiquavers.
This is incorrect. It's fairly obvious that both editors placed slurs on those semiquavers to assist in articulation. They must have assumed that this passage of 16 semiquavers was too difficult for the Clarinetist to tongue all of these separately.
This is an excellent example where one can just ignore the editing and play the passage correctly as to pulse.
Would it be correct for those who couldn't tongue every semibreve , to just slur the whole of measure 83 ?

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Johnny Galaga

2013-11-09 01:19

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-09 02:08

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

davyd

2013-11-09 02:44

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

cigleris

2013-11-09 04:37

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-09 06:12

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Liquorice

2013-11-09 08:04

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Katrina

2013-11-09 12:39

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Lelia Loban

2013-11-09 15:26

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-09 15:55

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

MSK

2013-11-09 16:46

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

rmk54

2013-11-09 16:54

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-09 17:08

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Johnny Galaga

2013-11-09 19:14

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-09 20:12

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Liquorice

2013-11-09 20:14

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-09 21:07

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-09 21:40

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

kdk

2013-11-09 22:26

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-10 02:35

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

kdk

2013-11-10 03:55

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Andrez444

2013-11-10 08:29

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-10 12:17

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-10 15:43

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-10 17:48

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-10 18:06

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

kdk

2013-11-10 20:42

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Lelia Loban

2013-11-10 18:39

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 04:22

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

donald

2013-11-11 05:08

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

cigleris

2013-11-11 06:15

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 07:00

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 07:10

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 13:05

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Katrina

2013-11-11 14:42

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur?

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 16:42

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 18:02

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Barry Vincent

2013-11-11 20:25

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Arnoldstang

2013-11-11 21:33

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 21:41

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-11 23:03

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 23:54

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-11 17:46

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-12 10:22

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-12 13:54

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

DavidBlumberg

2013-11-12 13:55

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-12 14:13

Re: Staccatos Under A Slur? new

Tony Pay

2013-11-12 18:49

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.