The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke

Author: Tony Pay ★2017
Date: 2013-07-08 12:41

I suppose a good question to start with would be, why do YOU consider they 'deserve emotive playing'? In other words, what would have YOU decide WHICH emotions need to be portrayed?

Then you may start to get an handle on how to approach the music, which I suppose is the point of the exercise.

Emotion isn't like tomato ketchup. (That's just the one flavour, and it gets applied indiscriminately.)

Ken Shaw -- who I seem to be encountering at every turn at the moment -- previously pointed someone else towards Steven Isserlis's 'cello masterclass, which I didn't like much, and provided some musical ideas of his own, with which I disagreed.

Actually I dislike almost all 'cello players' take on these pieces: they have something of the tomato ketchup tendency. (You can hear them 'celebrating being wonderful performers' -- as if.)

An exception was the American Ronald Thomas, whom I found myself admiring -- despite his playing them 'on the wrong instrument':-)

Tony

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Schumann Fantasiestucke new

samsmash

2013-07-08 11:57

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke

Tony Pay

2013-07-08 12:41

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Tobin

2013-07-08 14:01

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Ken Shaw

2013-07-08 14:17

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Ken Shaw

2013-07-08 14:32

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

kdk

2013-07-08 14:54

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

kdk

2013-07-08 15:22

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Tony Pay

2013-07-08 15:25

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Tony Pay

2013-07-08 17:13

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Barry Vincent

2013-07-08 20:07

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Paul Aviles

2013-07-08 17:33

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Tony Pay

2013-07-08 18:05

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

kdk

2013-07-08 18:35

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Tony Pay

2013-07-08 18:44

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

davyd

2013-07-08 22:21

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

samsmash

2013-07-09 14:34

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

dtiegs

2013-07-11 01:50

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Ken Shaw

2013-07-11 13:37

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

DavidBlumberg

2013-07-11 14:06

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

DavidBlumberg

2013-07-11 14:08

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Tony Pay

2013-07-11 14:23

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

eac

2013-07-11 15:16

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Ken Shaw

2013-07-11 16:11

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Tobin

2013-07-11 16:47

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

DavidBlumberg

2013-07-11 16:48

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

DavidBlumberg

2013-07-11 16:49

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Jack Kissinger

2013-07-11 17:04

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

kdk

2013-07-11 17:11

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

davyd

2013-07-11 18:14

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

Ken Shaw

2013-07-11 18:45

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

eac

2013-07-11 19:25

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

DavidBlumberg

2013-07-13 13:11

Re: Schumann Fantasiestucke new

fernie51296

2013-07-13 04:30

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.