The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions?

Author: Matt Locker
Date: 2008-04-09 14:25

David:

I understand. I replied to the direction the thread took, not to the initial questions.

Unfortunately, the only real experiment we can look at is the Greenline. You believe the Greenline sounds different than an R13. Can you qualify how you think it's different? How large is the sample size? How was the "experiment" done & was each instrument properly maintained/setup? The real question is why do you think they are different? Is there something in the way they are designed/machined/produced that makes them sound different? Absent that, then it must be perceived differences.

Believe me, I believe that the body material makes a difference in the sound but only in how it's applied to the design. That same body material, used properly, should create the same sound as the reference instrument.

Thanks,
Matt

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 02:32

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

skygardener

2008-04-08 02:38

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

LonDear

2008-04-08 03:21

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 03:37

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Ed

2008-04-08 03:27

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

GBK

2008-04-08 03:33

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Vytas

2008-04-08 04:00

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 04:18

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Sinatra

2020-01-09 23:16

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Hank Lehrer

2008-04-08 04:12

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

S. Friedland

2008-04-08 14:20

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

rsholmes

2008-04-08 04:19

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Dano

2008-04-08 04:20

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

C2thew

2008-04-08 06:13

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

J. J.

2008-04-08 07:17

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 11:17

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Chris P

2008-04-08 09:13

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Merlin_Williams

2008-04-08 10:09

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

L. Omar Henderson

2008-04-08 11:12

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

kilo

2008-04-08 11:59

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

BobD

2008-04-08 13:37

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 13:42

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

patrickryan04

2008-04-08 14:09

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Hank Lehrer

2008-04-08 14:45

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

L. Omar Henderson

2008-04-08 15:31

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

clarinetist04

2008-04-08 16:33

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 16:53

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Ed

2008-04-08 17:00

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

GBK

2008-04-08 17:18

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 17:37

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Bob Phillips

2008-04-08 17:26

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

J. J.

2008-04-08 17:35

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

L. Omar Henderson

2008-04-08 17:48

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Ed

2008-04-08 17:59

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

GBK

2008-04-08 18:01

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 18:15

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Chris P

2008-04-08 18:04

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

S. Friedland

2008-04-08 18:39

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 19:38

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Paul Aviles

2008-04-08 19:34

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

BobD

2008-04-08 20:32

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

patrickryan04

2008-04-08 21:14

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Jkelly32562

2008-04-08 21:37

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-08 21:59

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Chris P

2008-04-08 22:12

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Ed

2008-04-08 23:28

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Ryder

2008-04-09 00:29

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

skygardener

2008-04-09 03:05

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-09 04:10

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

C2thew

2008-04-09 06:06

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Dan Shusta

2008-04-09 06:55

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

stevensfo

2008-04-09 09:13

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-09 12:40

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

skygardener

2008-04-09 10:49

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

patrickryan04

2008-04-09 10:53

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Chris P

2008-04-09 11:29

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

BobD

2008-04-09 13:17

Re: Why aren't plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Gordon (NZ)

2008-04-09 13:18

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Matt Locker

2008-04-09 13:24

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-09 13:41

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

rsholmes

2008-04-09 16:00

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions?

Matt Locker

2008-04-09 14:25

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

skygardener

2008-04-09 15:00

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Chris P

2008-04-09 15:02

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

rtmyth

2008-04-09 15:13

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

clarinetist04

2008-04-09 15:20

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Chris P

2008-04-09 15:29

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Paul Aviles

2008-04-09 15:40

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Sylvain

2008-04-09 15:48

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2008-04-09 16:40

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Avie

2008-04-09 17:39

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Chris P

2008-04-09 17:47

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Paul Aviles

2020-01-10 00:41

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Tony F

2020-01-10 03:17

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

DavidBlumberg

2020-01-11 20:05

Re: Why arent plastic clarinets made with wooden dimensions? new

Sinatra

2020-01-14 02:27

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.