Author: allencole
Date: 2004-12-04 16:53
On Buffet B10 vs. B12. I would definitely go with the B12. The B10 was apparently an attempt to compete with cheaper instruments, and some of its mechanics can be high-maintenance.
The B-12 is a solid horn as are the Selmers (301 and 1401, I think)
My biggest concern with a small girl are small fingers covering the tone holes. The Yamaha YCL-23 and most of the Vitos are going to be easier to cover than the Buffet or the Selmer as far as I can tell. Selmer has the largest tone holes of all, and I normally steer small young girls away from them if I can.
With Vito, I think that the 7212, 7213, and 7214 are mechanically the same. The 7414, if I recall, has a dull finish designed to look more like wood. Not sure about the 7213--are these the colored ones? I believe that the 7212 is the basic model that most will want. You might get more info from the Woodwind/Brasswind website, at www.wwbw.com. There is also a version of the 7214 (7214P) that has plateau (covered) keys instead of the normal rings.
The 7242 is a smaller-bore instrument which characteristics more like those that are popular with professionals today. I've never tried one. Not sure about the V40. Didn't see it on their website.
You might also try Googling the model numbers.
Now what I REALLY think:
Forte is worth taking a chance on if you can get one. Good reviews and good price. If I didn't have a Greenline, I'd probably try one. Resale is less of a concern with a plastic horn, because most players keep theirs.
I like the Buffet B12 and the Vito 7212, but with a small girl I'd put the 7212 on top, or consider a Yamaha YCL-23. We want those little fingers to be able to seal the tone holes, and those are reputable models that will give her the best chance.
Look at your rental-purchase contract. You may have the option to trade models at purchase, and there may insurance features that minimize repair costs etc. Rentals are more expensive, but they are not a ripoff. If this instrument works for your daughter, or if you can substitute something else you want, why not just do business with your local store? They have made this possible for you to do risk-free, and to pay by installments. They will provide you with convenient repairs, lessons, and supplies for years to come--if they can make enough money to stay open. Consider the wider picture before acting on a narrow issue.
Allen Cole
Post Edited (2004-12-04 17:49)
|
|
The Clarinet BBoard
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
