The Clarinet BBoard
|
Author: Britbrit
Date: 2004-04-28 16:38
I am restoring an old clarinet (Bajus dating from about 1920) to something approaching its former glory. I have done the pads but for gluing the cork seals between sections I don't know what glue to use and I can't find any info on the net. Any ideas ?
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: coasten1
Date: 2004-04-28 17:30
your ordinary rubber cement works..
just apply it to both surfaces and let dry about 10 minutes.. carefully place the cork on the joint because you will not be able to reseat the cork once you get a stick. sand off the excess cork until you get the correct fit.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: ron b
Date: 2004-04-28 17:54
Hi, Britbrit
I'd like to hear more about your instrument since a lot of us are interested in the 'historical' ones. Why it appealed to you in the first place. Why you decided to fix it. Things like that.
Cork glue. What did you use to install the pads? Chances are good that the same stuff will serve for adhering the tenon and key cork as well. However...
Historically... up until the '50s and 60's, in my experience, shellac (stick) was commonly used to adhere cork to just about everything. The cork is first cut to a proper width and a little longer than the circumference. One end of the cork is then beveled, about 45 degrees or so. A small spatula, sorta like a little butter knife, was heated over an alcohol lamp flame and used to heat and smear the shellac onto the tenon surfaces. Then the shellac was heated, a small section at a time, while the cork was pressed into place, going 'round the tenon and ending with the beveled end overlapped a bit. The seam end was then sanded to make the cork's circumference even all around the tenon - then reduced if necessary to make a snug fit into the socket. Apply your favorite cork grease in the usual manner. All in all, a rather messy and time consuming process.
Nowadays... nearly all repairers use contact cement; the kind you find in hardware stores and home improvement centers does a good job. Thin when necessary, to a not too thin but runny consistency, with M.E.K. (methyl ethyl keytones). Caution: it's highly flammable.
Another caution: DO NOT use "contact cement thinner" sold by hardware stores - it's a Remover, not a thinner. Use it only as an after-use Cleaner. If you add it to contact cement it'll ruin it's adhesive properties. Use M.E.K. for thinning -- which you'll find at the same store where you purchase contact cement.
Cut your cork in the usual manner. Thinly coat both the tenon area to be corked and the cork surface, one side only, including the beveled end surface, that's to be stuck to it. Allow ten minutes for both coated surfaces to dry. Beginning with the beveled end, begin wrapping the cork around the tenon and finally ending with the end overlapping and sticking to the bevel. Trim off the end and sand evenly all 'round to a snug fit. Apply your favorite cork lubricant.
Now you can clean up any contact cement with a thinner-moistened cloth or just rub it off with your fingers. Much less time involved, easier cleanup and the cork should be free of any bumps you often get with the shellac method.
Contact cement is also used for corking keys in the same manner. Coat both surfaces, apply when dry (test with a fingerNAIL, not your [oily] skin) then trim with a sharp blade.
- rn b -
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: ron b
Date: 2004-04-28 18:06
I don't mean to jump in and take issue, Coasten1. but it's important to use the correct terminology. If you don't ask for, or know what it is you need - you might get the wrong stuff. Not many things are worse in our daily experiences than trying to make the wrong stuff do the right job.
Besides... there's no such thing as 'rubber cement'. Read the label, it's 'paper cement'. It's not suitable for tenon or key corks; not nearly strong enough. It's designed to hold paper together. Contact cement was designed to hold shoe repairs together; it's strong enough.
-rb-
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Wayne Thompson
Date: 2004-04-28 18:18
So, I'm restoring my first clarinet, and soaking up advice like this when it comes around. Here's a related question. How important is it to get the old stuff off? I have an old Cartier (why? because I read here that it is sort of a pro quality and it was cheap on eBay). The tenons are grooved and coated with I don't know what. It might be contact cement; it's still somewhat flexible. I haven't tried yet; it looks hard to remove. Regardless, do you all clean the tenons completely every time and do you use MEK, acetone, alcohol, or does it matter?
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Wayne Thompson
Date: 2004-04-28 18:32
I'll refine my question. I find that 91% isopropyl alcohol works ok for my rubbery old glue, so I'm sure if I experiment I'll get it off somehow. (I notice that it does easily wipe away some of the black stain, so I just learned about that.)
However my real question is whether you remove old shellac before using contact cement, and if so how?
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: CPW
Date: 2004-04-28 22:10
Gorrilla glue.
lightly moisten the cork with tiny bit of water. Glue, wrap, wait 30 min then sand.
wear gloves....stains hands brown like tobacco.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: mw
Date: 2004-04-28 23:10
Speaking of Adhesive (Glue, Contact Cement, etc) for Cork installation, I consider myself a junkee. NO, I don't abuse it. BUT, I have tried them all. Votaw's is the worst (sorry, I love everything else about their catalogue & equipment). Ferree's product (which is supposed to be the same as the Votaw in a different can) is fine stuff. Leblanc adhesive is pretty good, too.
However, all these adhesives have one thing in common. They require ONE PASS over an area. If you take a 2nd pass, you won't generally like the result. "Sticky-too-sticky" don't work so good.
Not true with the Ed Myer's adhesive. In fact, it does better when you give it the once over. That's the way Ed markets it. If you are not sure if you applied a sufficient quantity or if youn see a spot which you missed, simply give it the once over.
AND, then - when it's good to go on --- man, it's tough to get off! AND, that's the kind of cork installation you want - no movement, cork to surface adhering w/a strong bond. The Ed Myer's catalogue offers a lot of great ideas.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: BobD
Date: 2004-04-28 23:37
Well, my "rubber cement" is labelled as such and it is mainly for temporary mounting of thingees on paper....photos, for example. I agree, it probably won't work too good for cork but I've never used it for that. Check the search function here as there are many posts on what to use. If you're not concerned about removing the cork you attach sometime in the future ....lucky you. Some here use hot glue....I don't. I use Ferree's Micro whatever in a little tube.....it's been around longer than I have.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: mw
Date: 2004-04-29 00:47
Not Ferree's brand per se. IMMSMR, Micro is a shellac-type adhesive --- really a generic brand. Many music stores sell Micro brand products. Pads, you name it. mw
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: ron b
Date: 2004-04-29 00:51
Someone at Ferree's told me a couple of years ago that they'd quit making Micro cement (shellac in a tube). So, I've never tried it. Repairers tell me they didn't like it because was messy. So far, I've been quite pleased with other products.
You could make your own Micro using denatured alcohol and flake shellac I suppose, but why bother?
-rb
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: jim lande
Date: 2004-04-29 02:13
I have used stuff call 'rubber cement' With much trial and error, you can get it to hold. However once cork grease has been on for a while the rubber cement gets sticky and the cork sheds. Total failure. I bought stuff from Ferrees and redid everything. That has been fine.
Just remember to keep the lid screwed on tight. Once it tries out you have to buy more.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: ron b
Date: 2004-04-29 05:47
I find the same thing, Jim. Rubber (paper) cement will not withstand as much stress as contact cement to begin with and any grease or oil will spoil its bonding qualities. It'll shorten the lifetime of contact cement as well.
Cheer up, though; there's a way to slow, although maybe not completely arrest, the action. Working plenty of paraffin wax into fresh cork will delay the penetration of grease through the cork to the cement. You apply the wax after you have a good snug fit but before applying any grease. Do all your sanding/fitting before waxing. It's kinda tricky getting the paraffin into the cork though, so you might want to take it to an experienced corker the first time and ask if you can observe. Your local tech may or may not know about this technique so you may have to ask around 'til you find one who does.
Short explanation: the waxing is done by rubbing the cork liberally (moderately aggressive) with paraffin, then heat over an open flame - allow to cool. Repeat the process until the cork is thoroughly waxed. All the pores should be filled in with wax. Then use a small amount of cork grease.
A dab of Dr. Slick 'should' last at least a century*
Caution: the danger is that you might burn the cork if your reflexes aren't quick. You need to heat just enough to melt the wax but not burn the cork. Do it incrementally, with a slight twisting motion, one-quarter to maybe one-third turn at a time.
[ I just had a thought. Maybe a (hair) blow dryer would do as well. I haven't tried this, but it might work. ]
Anyway, waxed cork will outlast unwaxed cork by a very long time - guaranteed
_____________________________
* well... maybe a little less :\
rb
Post Edited (2004-04-29 05:51)
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Gordon (NZ)
Date: 2004-04-29 06:30
MW wrote "BUT, I have tried them all." How about Evostik.
I, here in NZ, like technicians I've heard in Germany, and UK, use Evostik Impact Adhesive.
I far prefer it to Ferrees. I have soaked the set stuff in acetone, lighter fluid, and oils, and it resists wonderfully. I apply it thinly and it is ready for attaching the cork within about a minute. It comes in a 70g tube with a very thin nozzle, which makes it far easier to apply. I actually jam some 1 mm O.D. teflon tube in the nozzle, and don't need to close the lid. No problem with evaporation. It does not suffer from 'creep' when small corks are attached to keys.
Unfortunately this adhesive, made by a major UK adhesives manufacturer, Bostik Findley ltd, seems to be unavailable in USA.
I cannot understand why Ferrees does not sell it, seeing their seemingly associate distributor in UK, Windcraft, sells it.
Wayne, It is very rare indeed for me to have to remove corks I have installed. However for other corks, I remove all that is not highly resistant, but definitely include lumpy bits. I use a combination of scraping, rubbing, along with the softening action of lighter fluid, with acetone added for the obstinate stuff, but no acetone near plastic!
BTW contact adhesives are definitely not all equal. Many types in hardware stores set far too gooey to take the sliding hiding that tenon corks get, and many are very readily softened by cork greases.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Mark Pinner
Date: 2004-04-29 10:55
Another good product out of Europe is Bison which is made in Holland. I still use locally produced Selley's or Bostik contact adhesive. I was taught the old method of burning shellac which really sticks the cork but takes ages, so does Micro which is a pre mixed shellac alchohol mixture. For those of us that might do 100 or more corking operations per week, contact adhesive is the way to go. It is also easy to remove compared to burned shellac. I still do yarn tenons on request, especially on bassoons.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Britbrit
Date: 2004-04-29 11:11
Hi, Ron,
Thanks for your interest. This old clarinet was lying on the window sill of a restaurant next to an old accordeon, both being there as conversation pieces and for ornamental value. When I asked if I could try it, the restaurant owner said that it hadn't been touched for at least 30 years and was in a bad state. The bad state was a modest description but I got something resembling a clarinet sound out of it. On further inspection it appeared that the pads and corks needed redoing, some oiling and a general overhaul. Most surprisingly the wood is in very good condition (no apparent cracks and having replaced the pads I can confirm the good state of the wood because closing off all fingerholes and the bottom, a good suck at the top gives vacuum that is pretty good).
I had to straighten some of the keys out but a blow torch and gentle persuading soon got the maillechort alloy into place. I am now at a point where I'm resiting the corks (pads and joints) so which is why I was looking for the info.
According to the restaurant owner, the instruments dates from the 1st World War but I haven't found any trace of the makers yet.
My brother used to play clarinet and recently gave a pair of matched Noblet Artiste Bb and A as a present to my son (about 40 year old instruments). I got round to playing them and so my interest developped.
there have been many useful comments, thanks for yours and I'll be back soon with more questions.
Ciao !
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Mark Charette
Date: 2004-04-29 11:54
Gordon (NZ) wrote:
> Unfortunately this adhesive, made by a major UK adhesives
> manufacturer, Bostik Findley ltd, seems to be unavailable in
> USA.
>
No, after a quick look it appears to be available at hobby shops, where it is used to attach mylar film to wooden frames for R/C model aircraft
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: mw
Date: 2004-04-29 12:37
Hello, Gordon. I have the Evostick - got it from Windcraft. It's fine stuff, but I haven't seen anything that works like Ed Myer's "goo" does. You can reapply an area. Never a mistake or problem. Holds like it was welded. best, mw
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Gordon (NZ)
Date: 2004-04-29 14:37
If Evostik dries too much on me, I reapply. No problem, as long as I spread it quickly. No tool works as well as a finger!
Good to hear the Myers is good though. But surely it dries before you use the can, with all that surface area exposed to the air every time you open it. I really like not having to mess around with thinners.
Thanks for the info, Mark. Many people have told me they couldn't get it in USA. I wish the balsa wood glue I bought for my son had a nozzle as fine as the Evostik's.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: mw
Date: 2004-04-29 16:56
Gordon, I don't know about others. BUT, I frequently deal with Windcraft on out of date parts & (merely) asked my contact there "can you ship Evostik to the States?" & the rest is history. I buy Myers' thinner, too. Frankly, his cost in quantity is cheap. I close up my adhesives. Ferree's charges as much for their can as they do for the contact cement! Myer's has a lot of practical/interesting ideas. I like his "burn in Glue" which works well with Sax pads and the large Cups on Clarinets (bass & alto esp.) - this is a very thick (liquid) shellac. It's in Ed's catalogue. I had my doubts originally, but it works well. best, mw
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: mw
Date: 2004-04-29 22:44
Gordon - FYI - a review of the product info for the Ed Myers' Contact Glue - "... dries slower than (regular) quick dry."
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Gordon (NZ)
Date: 2004-05-01 07:34
mw - ".......'can you ship Evostik to the States?' & the rest is history..."
Interesting. I've never bought from them, but I did enquire and they said no shipping problems.
Perhaps the shipping problem for you is at the USA end.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: mw
Date: 2004-05-01 13:40
Gordon, you need to re-read. I said had NO PROBLEMS buying the Evostik.
I have 2 tubes of it here in the States.
BUT, like I also said - I don't think Evostik quite measures up to some of these other adhesives.
best,
mw
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Gordon (NZ)
Date: 2004-05-01 14:44
Sorry, mw. Your colloquial language ("the rest was history") in the statement I quoted, mislead me.
I think every glue has idiosyncrasies in the way it is ideally used, and perhaps the one we perceive to be best is the one where have hit upon the ideal way to use it.
BTW did you get the small tube, the large tube, or a can? How do you spread it?
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Dan1937
Date: 2004-05-01 14:47
Permatex Brand Automotive Weatherstrip Adhesive has been mentioned as a superior substitute (or replacement) for contact cement by several repair techs on saxophone web sites. I'm sure it's available at auto parts stores.
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Alseg
Date: 2004-05-01 17:51
Hi.
I am a woodworker/turner in spare time (yeh, spare time, right) and I found that Gorilla glue works ok on tenon corks BUT you can find all sorts of neat glues in woodcraft stores....shellacs, resins, etc.
Woodworkers Supply, Packard, etc have online shops and some have retail stores. Some of the glues are pricey.
I sat in Moennig's shop one cold day in 1960s and watched as his assistant Cazimer glued a tenon cork for me onto an old ES middle joint....he used molten shellac stick then turned it on a lathe to shape. (and he didnt have to remove the bridge key)
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: mw
Date: 2004-05-01 18:21
Agree, Gordon it's a very tactile & "sticky" subject! [sorry couldn't resist!]
Permatex is recommended by more than a few repair people - it's use has been echoed on the Napbirt thread - notably by Steve Goodson (SaxGourmet) & other Napbirt guru's. It is available @ Autozone, etc.
Certainly, one would try to avoid a situation where a *different* glue/adhesive/contact cement is used for each (type) instrument; rather most techs try & utilize 1 brand of adhesive that will suit a variety of (installation) purposes. Many use Contact Cement for Clarinet, Oboe, etc. but use Shellac for Sax pads, etc.
**************************
We've mentioned Ferree's, Ed Myer's, Votaw, etc. My point in mentioning these suppliers has been 2-fold (or more).
1. These are vendorss where you can buy excellent quality Contact Cements (equal to the quality that most techs use - not to say that you can't buy adhesives locally- but I am picky and have been happier with purchases from these suppliers). (free) Catalogues are available. Novices can learn simply by reading the Catalogues, to be sure.
[ certain suppliers like Allied, Kraus, the Manufacture, etc. will ONLY sell to the Trade - definitions & requirements vary as to what constitutes "trade" ]
2. Besides offering Adhesive, they Vendors (all) sell excellent quality Pads & Cork (& specialty tools & other supplies like hycotek-style cork, felt, fishskin, feeler gauges, etc.). The Pads (& other supplies) you can get are superior and vary in quality & style (thick, thin, plush, hard, leather, fishskin, cork, valentino style, etc.). This is very important if you are trying to MAINTAIN quality, etc. If you have been using inferior Pads - an entire new world is available to you. [be advised that these same vendors also sell some crap too - like anything else caveat emptor - ask questions - vendors like Votaw are happy to answer questions]
Very few people will be successful doing their own repair work without a Mentor or Course Study or hands-on assistance - very few, yet there are some who will be succeed. Those that succeed have an aptitude, strong engineerring or repair background, were born to it, etc.
Most who dabble will find that they end up wasting their money & that they do more "damage or messing up" by attempting instrument repair & maintenance.
None of the foregoing is meant to discourage, rather it's simply to relay the odds for success.
Post Edited (2004-05-02 02:13)
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
The Clarinet Pages
|
|