The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Orsi and Weir Clarinets

Author: jgarzatx
Date: 2006-02-21 03:15

I was just at the annual TMEA show in San Antonio. I had a good 30 minute chat with both John and Patti Weir, as well as a nice opportunity to give their instruments a go. Here's what I thought:

1. Definitely liked the American taper to the European. I also was trying these intstruments out in a convention hall, but it was the smaller of the two TMEA had this year. The response from the American taper seemed evident from the get go, where as the European seemed to give a little resistance. Of the barrel styles offered, I also liked the A1 the best as it seemed to be less restrictive of the air flow between the mouthpiece and body.

2. Tuning was difficult to judge, being in an exhibit hall, but the notes seemed to flow easily and smoothly from bottom to top.

3. After talking to Patti, I was pleased about the options they are making available. As noted, some Orsi clarinets have the LH/Eb lever, whereas others do not. I was informed that this is going to be a "by request" option. After talking with many clarinetists Patti said most preferred to either not have the extra key, or have it be an option. I was also told the Eb lever would be a no cost option when requested. I also liked that the wood is left unstained. I loved the way the instruments jumped out (much like other makers have been doing). Also Patti said that if a custom taper was wanted (such as from a blown out or non-functioning barrel of old) that it could be made to match the clarinet.

4. I didn't notice so many differences in the bell tapers, however I am interested in experimenting with these as well.

5. There is an A clarinet in development. Patti had a "work in progress" model that she let me play on to get an opinion on the feel of the instrument. What I tested seemed rough, unfinished, but well on the way to a great instrument. I'll be anxious to try one of their A models when they are finished.

6. Lastly: I have a set of Buffet Vintages that I LOVE to play on, and in my mind/ear, the American taper Orsi played about equal to my Vintage Bb. The keywork was right on par with some of the better clarinets I've tried, and it felt basically like I was holding my own clarinet in my hands. Very comfortable and enjoyable.

My two (or six) cents.

JGarza

Just another clarinet teacher in TX, anyone need an assistant band director? ;-)

Affiliated with: TMEA, MENC, Phi Mu Alpha Sinfonia, Kappa Kappa Psi National Honorary Band Fraternity

Interim Clarinet Teacher: La Joya High School

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics