The Clarinet BBoard
|
Author: Tony Pay ★2017
Date: 2008-12-23 16:31
Sacha wrote:
>> Does anyone have any information as to which edition of this Schumann trio is the most 'correct'?>>
Judging by the Henle edition of the Fantasiestuecke , I think that the Henle edition of this piece too would give you the most complete information. And I'm almost sure there is one -- but I only have the Breitkopf.
>> It's also very unclear to me where the trills in the first mvt. should go, any ideas?>>
The key to understanding this is to appreciate that an accidental beside the 'tr' refers not to the trill itself but to the pitch of the nachschlag. So in bar 8 the trill is a semitone, E to F natural, but the nachschlag is D#E. In bar 30 the trill is a whole tone, E to F# (accidental ABOVE the 'tr') and in fact Schumann writes out the nachschlag D#E (though I suppose he could have written another # beside the 'tr'). In bar 46 the trill is again a semitone, B to C, and again the # beside the 'tr' refers to the nachschlag A#B.
Similar considerations govern the trills in the last movement of the Rhenish Symphony, which as you know we've just been doing.
Tony
|
|
|
srattle |
2008-12-20 19:47 |
|
Re: Schumann Märchenerzahlungen |
|
Tony Pay |
2008-12-23 16:31 |
|
The Clarinet Pages
|
|