The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos

Author: Alexis
Date: 2006-12-30 06:49

For those who know this solo (the trio of the 3rd mvt):

Are the piano subito's absolutely essential? And if so, why?

The Hadcock book has them in as editorial additions, and I understand that this may just reflect the way they are usually performed. There seem to be a lot of other instances in Beethoven where a crescendo is followed by a subito piano - I know Daniel Barenboim in particular speaks a lot about this in his conversations with Edward Said.

But I have been playing this excerpt the same way for about 3 years now, and it occurred to me today that it doesn't make much sense to me played like that. Is it possible that Beethoven just forgot to mark in the diminuendos and assumed the performer would interpolate them?

I have to admit I haven't listened to recordings with this in mind recently - just picked up the excerpt again today.

Thoughts?

Post Edited (2006-12-30 07:08)

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Alexis

2006-12-30 06:49

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Ken Shaw

2006-12-30 13:18

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2006-12-30 23:38

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

DAVE

2006-12-31 19:38

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-01 22:22

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Alexis

2007-01-01 00:00

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-10 15:40

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-10 17:13

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Dick

2007-01-10 18:47

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-10 21:14

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-11 06:49

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-10 23:03

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

diz

2007-01-11 22:32

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-11 23:01

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

diz

2007-01-11 23:12

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-11 23:36

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-12 01:54

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

donald

2007-01-12 11:13

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-12 13:35

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Mark Charette

2007-01-12 13:41

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-12 13:48

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-12 16:18

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-14 19:26

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

bufclar

2007-01-12 16:58

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

charlie_star_uk

2007-01-15 07:52

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

charlie_star_uk

2007-01-15 07:59

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-15 14:23

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

bufclar

2007-01-15 15:09

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-15 15:17

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

diz

2007-01-15 22:01

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-15 23:02

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

donald

2007-01-15 23:44

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Tony Pay

2007-01-16 09:07

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-16 00:05

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

Liquorice

2007-01-16 06:16

Re: Beethoven 8 3rd mvt solo - piano subitos new

D Dow

2007-01-16 10:39

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.