The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Weber: and underrated composer?

Author: kdk ★2017
Date: 2019-12-29 03:35

brycon wrote:

> Yes, the Baermann editions do give you insight into one
> "playing style." But the playing style of 1869 may not be the
> same as that of 1811.

The notes in the Henle edition say that Carl's rendering was based on his father's handwritten performance notations. There's no way to know, of course, what edits and embellishments really are Carl and what are Heinrich.

> I agree, though, urtext editions can indeed be problematic.
> (And at any rate, they aren't an urtext: someone's
> edited them.)

So often, it seems, the original MS score isn't available so a first edition or a set of MS performance parts are used as a basis. So "urtext" needs some definition in a modern edition that describes itself that way. Henle's notes are extensive with regard to both the "urtext" part (the piano score that most of us buy is, of course, an edited reduction) and the Baermann version.

Karl

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-09 15:45

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Paul Aviles

2019-12-09 19:06

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-09 21:32

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-10 20:54

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

dorjepismo

2019-12-09 22:19

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-09 23:48

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

dorjepismo

2019-12-10 00:00

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

brycon

2019-12-10 00:54

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-10 18:27

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

kdk

2019-12-10 01:12

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

oldreedguy

2019-12-10 04:22

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-10 18:16

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

brycon

2019-12-10 20:55

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Kalashnikirby

2019-12-10 21:03

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-10 21:11

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Chris P

2019-12-11 00:46

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Plonk

2019-12-11 01:11

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

donald

2019-12-11 11:39

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Kalashnikirby

2019-12-11 12:21

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-11 14:08

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Jarmo Hyvakko

2019-12-28 10:46

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

ruben

2019-12-28 11:25

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

rmk54

2019-12-28 18:27

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

brycon

2019-12-28 20:01

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Jarmo Hyvakko

2019-12-28 21:09

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

kdk

2019-12-29 03:35

Re: Weber: and underrated composer? new

Tony Pay

2019-12-31 19:07

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.