Author: Bill
Date: 2000-11-30 23:54
Three months ago I started playing clarinet with a new rental Yamaha CL-20 plastic clarinet. It sounded nice, it had a nice feel, the key action was very good, and it was generally well made. It made me want to play a lot, which I did. I couldn’t imagine a clarinet being better. The 4C mouthpiece is very nice, but since I planned to return the clarinet, I purchased a Fobes Debut mouthpiece which (for me) is as nice as the 4C. The case is very compact, and very well made.
A couple of weeks ago, I tried some professional model clarinets, and the Buffet B-12 plastic clarinet. The B-12 felt lighter, smaller around, and I liked its wood grain finish. It sounded similar to the Yamaha, but I was using the Fobes mouthpiece.
I returned the Yamaha, and purchased a Buffet B-12. I am very disappointed. There is some slight play in the keys, and the action feels sluggish (I guess this could be adjusted). I find some of the little finger keys awkward to reach (is this my imagination?). Based on what people have said on this board, the mouthpiece should be replaced. The case is another big disappointment. It is cheaply made, compared to the Yamaha case, and the handle position makes it awkward to use the latch.
So, today I ordered a Yamaha CL-20, and I will be returning the Buffet. The prices are about the same, and with the Yamaha you get a decent mouthpiece, and a very nice case.
This is my experience, and others may have more postive experiences and opinions. . I know the Buffet B-12 is frequently recommended for beginners, but my experience make me wonder. Maybe I got an exceptional Yamaha or Buffet.
|
|
The Clarinet BBoard
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
.jpg){kind=small}
