The Clarinet BBoard

The Clarinet BBoard The C4 standard

New Topic | Go to Top | Go to Topic | Search | Help/Rules | Smileys/Notes | Log In

Previous Message | Next Message

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur

Author: Philip Caron
Date: 2008-06-10 00:34

The first pass, I only listened to Ms. Sabur's posted recordings and ignored the rest. I wrongly assumed she was supposed to be a musical prodigy and rising musical star. In that context, the recordings are a disappointment (and one does not need to be able to play perfectly in tune in order to detect out-of-tune playing.)

After revisiting the site and reading the rest, I'm much more impressed, but in an off-topic way. David's right - this lady is likely to do some great things, and it's a pleasure to see someone working hard to develop and use such gifts as hers. She has my full respect. But it's mostly off-topic here.

To my ears, her clarinet playing is very good for a non-professional. However, it doesn't flabbergast me like that of certain young (and not young) specialists in the instrument, many posts of whom have been pointed out in this forum recently.

Again, I point out that listening and commenting on what one hears need not require expert playing skills in oneself to be valid.

Reply To Message | Avail. Forums | Flat View

Newer Topic | Older Topic

Topics

Author

Date

Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Old Geezer

2008-06-06 16:51

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

William

2008-06-06 18:00

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Sylvain

2008-06-06 19:05

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

S. Friedland

2008-06-08 14:21

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Katrina

2008-06-07 00:27

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-07 01:17

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Iceland clarinet

2008-06-07 03:12

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

crnichols

2008-06-07 04:47

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

RodRubber

2008-06-07 05:59

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

kev182

2008-06-07 07:31

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Morrigan

2008-06-07 07:38

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-07 11:28

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

atasic

2008-06-07 12:33

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Old Geezer

2008-06-07 15:56

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-07 16:15

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

C2thew

2008-06-07 19:41

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-07 20:38

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Iceland clarinet

2008-06-07 23:09

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

crnichols

2008-06-08 16:16

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Iceland clarinet

2008-06-08 17:01

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur

S. Friedland

2008-06-08 17:55

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-08 19:12

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-08 20:21

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

S. Friedland

2008-06-08 20:27

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-08 20:49

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

rgames

2008-06-08 22:29

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

Old Geezer

2008-06-09 17:08

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-09 17:17

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

rgames

2008-06-10 01:08

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

C2thew

2008-06-09 17:29

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-09 17:59

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur

Philip Caron

2008-06-10 00:34

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

DavidBlumberg

2008-06-10 01:15

Re: Super Clarinet Prodigy Alia Sabur new

allencole

2008-06-11 04:20

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale

The Clarinet Pages

For Sale
Put your ads for items you'd like to sell here. Free! Please, no more than two at a time - ads removed after two weeks.