The Clarinet BBoard
|
Author: john gibson
Date: 2005-06-10 15:48
Okay....I posted several different sax sites and get such differing views and opinions that I'm thinking sax players are even more finicky than those of us who play blackwood.....
Anyway....my question is....what would be better...a crystal or wood MPC for saxophone?....I'm partial to both. Either will be used on a C melody. I know....I know...best to use a C mel mpc, which I have but would like to try something different as well....
REED ??? Do bass clarinet reeds work on tenor mpc's? And C melody reeds...are they the same as tenor just shorter? HELPPPPP...and thanks
JG
Oh yeah.....is a c mel mpc the same size as an alto....just uses tenor size reeds? I'm curious because I'd ike to get a better lig and am not sure what size fits.....AAAARRRGGGHHHH
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: Steve Epstein
Date: 2005-06-10 16:58
I just played my C-mel (Conn, alto-style neck) for the first time in an electric blues jam last night. "Electric" means playing with screaming electric guitars ala Jimi Hendrix, guys who haul in enough sound equipment to stock a store, all sorts of pedals on the floor, etc.
I had used previously my modern, student model alto, believing it was the most appropriate horn I have for this sort of venue, as I don't own a tenor, which is the "standard". I've even played clarinet. I was actually (with a microphone) quite loud enough on clarinet, but a bit out of character. So, last night I brought my soprano (a WW and BW store model) and my C-melody and tried them both.
To my surprise, the soprano wasn't any better than the alto. It sounded "lost" like my alto does, even though it was miked and loud enough. And the uncomfortable position of holding it near the microphone plus my nerves kept making my thumb slip off the octave key, so I couldn't take real advantage of the higher register, while losing the bottom of the alto's lower register.
Then I tried my C-melody. Boy did that turn heads, literally! I had to back away from the mike. I grunted as well as any tenor. I had a full, sonorous tenor sound. I got genuine complements from the veteran guitar players, instead of the usual just friendly encouragements.
And, I used the mp I always use: my Brillhart #3 tenor mp. Hard rubber with a white patch (that I've had to cover up with a black mp patch to keep my teeth from sliding). No metal. No special C-mel mp, either. No problems with volume, tone or intonation. Tenor reeds, of course.
So my real point (other than to tell this story) is not to obsess over how to equip your horn, just go play it. Certainly, if I were a pro, I couldn't get away with a C-mel in place of a tenor, but I was able to fool some hard-drinkin', hard-smokin' amateur but highly skilled rock and blues guys along with an equally hard-drinkin', hard-smokin' audience.
Don't waste your time with special mp's, unless you find you really need to after experimenting with what you have. You probably will need a short shank mp like the Brillhart in order to play in tune, however. You can use an alto mp, but you will likely play sharp unless you pull way out, which will cause the low notes to gurgle. If you find the tenor mp is to wide for the neck, just take some adhesive tape and wrap it around the base of the cork a ways until the mp fits.
Hope this helps.
Steve Epstein
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: szyJYM
Date: 2005-06-10 17:35
I do know from experience (and lack of funds) that bari sax reeds work quite well on a contralto clarinet, so i'd imagine that flipping the script should work.
--Mike
Wide-eyed music student entering college this fall
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
Author: john gibson
Date: 2005-06-11 02:06
Thanks for the story Steve. I was a pro drummer in rock bands San Francisco in the 60's/70s so I know about the stacks of equipment. Appreciate your thoughts....and thanks GBK for the website info......
JG
|
|
Reply To Message
|
|
The Clarinet Pages
|
|