The Clarinet BBoard
|
Author: John Scorgie
Date: 1999-09-01 22:23
Susan -
Your question re black plastic v clear plastic could better be answered by a clarinet playing college chemistry major. Since none have yet volunteered an answer, I will do my best.
As I understand it, the color makes no difference because these modern thermoplastics or acrylic plastics can be made in any color of the rainbow, or clear. The basic material is the same.
Most of the mouthpiece makers offer their student (plastic) mouthpieces in black. Some offer them in clear plastic. At least one maker (Bilger?) offers you a choice between the two. Probably the only reason that some makers offer clear plastic mouthpieces is that there is a market demand for them due to their similarity in appearance to crystal (glass) mouthpieces.
So take your choice based on cosmetics. The reason that the clear plastic mouthpiece from maker X sounds different or responds different from the black plastic mouthpiece from maker Y is due to differences in design from maker to maker, and has nothing to do with the color of the mpce.
There is no "best" mouthpiece. Fortunately, these days you can buy excellent quality low priced mouthpieces (about $30) from several makers such as Fobes, Hawkins, Hite, Jewel, Pyne, Ridenour etc. If there is a good musical instrument dealer near you, they will have several of these "student" mpces in stock at all times.
Whatever you do, don't buy a crystal mouthpiece for a young player. Crystal is a fancy name for glass, and glass mouthpieces are very fragile at the tip. Young players have enough trouble trying to learn all of the elements that go into playing well without having to worry about fracturing the mpce tip each time the mpce is placed into the mouth.
|
|
|
Susan |
1999-08-31 22:33 |
|
Mark Charette |
1999-08-31 23:46 |
|
William Fuller |
1999-09-01 05:01 |
|
William Fuller |
1999-09-01 05:03 |
|
Daniel |
1999-09-01 06:07 |
|
John Scorgie |
1999-09-01 22:23 |
|
The Clarinet Pages
|
|