Klarinet Archive - Posting 001156.txt from 2002/06
From: "Kevin Callahan" <kionon@-----.com>
Subj: Re: [kl] Illiteratates - And question
Date: Sun, 30 Jun 2002 22:33:42 -0400
----- Original Message -----
From: "Gene Nibbelin" <gnibbelin@-----.com>
Subject: RE: [kl] Illiteratates - And question
> Callahan -
You may call me Kevin. I'm not used to being addressed by people as
"Callahan" without some sort of military rank. Granted if you have rank,
we'll have to change how we address each other.
> Touché on the misspelling. What it proves is that my language knowledge
> exceeds my typing ability.
That was Mr. Berwald, though I agreed with the sentiment.
> I know that this isn't a language List but when I see you American
> youngsters disregarding the rules of the written English language, it
> me because I know how important the art of writing is to ones success in
Disregarding is a purposeful act. As you may recall me saying, I am an
English major. I am a writer primarily. While I love music, it is a
secondary field of interest. People make mistakes. This is a clarinet list.
It is not an essay list. It is not even a clarinet essay list, though I am
sure those are welcome. As long as people try to make an effort I have no
problem with their mistakes. Granted, purposeful disregard is a completely
different thing. It upsets me as much as it does you.
Also I assume you are not American by your reference to "you American
youngsters." Isn't that a bit insulting and condescending? I believe it was
our President Truman who after hearing another general say "those British
bastards" he replied, "Call a man a bastard if you wish, but don't tie it to
the man's nationality." I am a youngster, that isn't America's fault, and I
had a good education, though it was public. Your reference to our public
school system is also not America's fault. If any political level is to be
blamed, it's the states. Here every school system differs by location. I can
assure you that Frisco High School, of Frisco, Texas is one of the best in
the state. I would go further to bet it's one of the best in the US. My
English teachers inspired me to become part of their ranks. I think they did
a wonderful job.
> In my business career I discarded many resumes after reading only
> about half of the cover letter because the poor writing immediately told
> that they were not educated enough to qualify for the job opening that we
That is quite a different forum from the Klarinet, is it not? Some of us are
professionals, but not all. We have expert players, university students
trying to get there (like myself), and high school students. You cannot
expect the kind of writing found in a resume to be found on such a list. Not
to mention it'd be a little dry wouldn't it? I don't recall any humour in
the last resume I filled out.
> The ability to write well and communicate well is very important for
> in life. When someone reads what you have written, they learn a great
> about you. Write well and you create a good impression. Write poorly and
> you create a poor impression. It is that simple.
I agree with your first sentence (obviously as my goal is to be an English
teacher), but not the second. People can draw conclusions from your writing,
but they may be wrong. Write well and you do create a good impression, but
it's not always necessary to create such a professional impression. In this
case I think the clarinet list is more about sharing our love of that
instrument. It can be a forum for improving our writing skills but only if
we do more than yell at those who do not write as they could.