Klarinet Archive - Posting 000446.txt from 1997/09
From: Roger Garrett <rgarrett@-----.edu>
Subj: Re: ending the GreenLine plastic/composite thread
Date: Tue, 9 Sep 1997 16:06:16 -0400
It is subjective to believe that a person decides, not by the blowing but
by the feeling! The tester certainly does not know if the person can
distinguish between them! A lot of talk about scientific process
.....when the bottom line is, using the hands on a horn does in fact
affect resistance of the air pressure. I certiainly would want to use my
own fingers over the horn than rely on someone else's ....or a machine for
On Tue, 9 Sep 1997, Jonathan Cohler wrote:
> 1. Use the same mouthpiece/reed/ligature, with the same player
> for all instruments.
> 2. Don't allow the player to touch the instrument. Have someone
> else finger notes for him.
> Now, if the instruments have precisely the same blowing/sound
> characteristics, the same player with the same setup will not be able to
> distinguish between them (in any statistically useful way). This has been
> demonstrated in experiment.
> On the other hand, people may certainly convince themselves that things
> sound or feel different when they, in fact. do not. But if they cannot do
> this with repeatability in blind experiments then it is meaningless.
> And certainly, people are entitled to have aesthetic preferences (plast vs.
> wood vs metal etc.).
> Jonathan Cohler