Klarinet Archive - Posting 000115.txt from 2005/11

From: or3mondtoby@-----.net (Ormondtoby Montoya)
Subj: Re: [kl] The Vienna Philharmonic and Women -- Bad News
Date: Tue, 08 Nov 2005 11:49:25 -0500

Ken, thank goodness there's always more than one way of looking at
things. Otherwise the human race probably would've inbred itself out
of existence by now.

> Ken=A0Wolman wrote:

> Three years ago I saw/heard the VP (Vienna
> Philharmonic) in Carnegie Hall. [snip]
> I bought the tickets. I went for the music, not
> the politics which are nevertheless
> deplorable. One of the works was Mahler's
> Titan Symphony (No. 1). It was a colossal
> performance. Viennese orchestra, no women
> in sight unless they brought along the harpist,
> Jewish composer. "Dr. Laura, I've got a moral
> dilemma"...sort of like Otto Klemperer or
> Daniel Barenboim conducting Wagner.

> Short answer: I know the failings, I love the
> music. Where do I draw the line at where
> politics overcomes aesthetics?

One of the people who was interviewed (in the transcript cited earlier)
asserted that there is a direct conflict between "purity of gender and
culture" and "results". That is, a single-gender orchestra of
culturally uniform musicians can do better than an orchestra of mixed
gender and cultural background, and this improved result excuses the
bigotry. (Perhaps there should be a Ladies' VPO ?)

In this sense, your words (quoted above) can be interpreted to reinforce
the transcript's claims. You describe the situation as a conflict
between beautiful music and ethics.

BUT THERE *IS* ANOTHER WAY OF LOOKING AT THIS WHICH IS EQUALLY AS
DEFENSIBLE !!!

We could say that VPO is a great orchestra (I've never heard them live
myself, so I don't know what I would think of their performance) simply
because they pay more money than most orchestras and therefore they
attract superior performers. Or perhaps they rehearse more often, or
play only German system clarinets or whatever.

But it is also possible that they could perform better if they did not
limit themselves to a narrow category of performers !! Is there a
musician in the VPO who could be replaced by a better performer if only
they allowed themselves to accept a female <name an ethnicity> musician
!?!

And wouldn't this be the ultimate 'put down' if you're looking for a
put-down? "Too bad you aren't able to hire <so-and-so>. Then you'd
be the best orchestra around, and I'd probably come to Vienna to enjoy
your music."

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Klarinet is a service of Woodwind.Org, Inc. http://www.woodwind.org

   
     Copyright © Woodwind.Org, Inc. All Rights Reserved    Privacy Policy    Contact charette@woodwind.org