Klarinet Archive - Posting 000643.txt from 2002/03

From: mixtapes8@-----.com
Subj: [kl] noblet vs. evette
Date: Fri, 22 Mar 2002 09:38:59 -0500

Hi everyone,

I've been a-lurking since I joined the list but have enjoyed many of the discussions going on here... now I am finally going to ask a question of my own. Here's the background first.

I'm studying seriously with the goal of eventually playing at least semi-professionally. Up until recently, I played on a Noblet that probably dates back to the late-60s (it was my uncle's, handed down to me as an elementary schooler). I felt it served me well over the years and I was able to get some nice sounds out of it. A few months ago I bought an Evette on eBay -- very cheaply -- that is from around the same era from what I can tell from the serial numbers, and had it refurbished. I've been playing on it since then and feel that I get a similar response from it.

My teacher, of course, tells me that I need to upgrade (he's big on the Buffet R-13, which was my dream horn growing up, and now, too I guess), and I would love to, like, yesterday, but lack the funds to do so anytime soon. I'm anxious to hear your thoughts about which horn I own now is looked upon as the better model, and maybe suggestions on where to go from here? The Noblet is in need of servicing, and as I said, the Evette was just re-corked and padded, etc.

I'm using an oldie, but goody mouthpiece that is not labeled but that my teacher thinks is an Opperman; I also have a Selmer B* in reserve. I just bought a Rovner Dark Ligature (which I really like, BTW) and also plan to get an Optimum (Optima?) per teacher's recommendation. I use Vandoren V12 reeds.

I think my ultimate question is, if you can make it sound good, is it really necessary to upgrade? I've had several positive comments about my tone and expressive playing. I mean, I realize that if I ever did play professionally, I'd really need to... but... does anyone happen to know of any professional players who made it on less than a pro model horn? Just curious. :)

One more thing "teach" says ;): it'd be like trying to ride in the Tour de France on a tricycle. Thoughts?

Sorry this was such a long post. Can't wait to read the responses!

Best regards,

Amy

---------------------------------------------------------------------
It's Sneezy.Org Pledge time. Please visit
http://www.sneezy.org/Pledge.html