Klarinet Archive - Posting 000664.txt from 1997/11

From: Ken Bryson <kbryson@-----.com>
Subj: top line model for beginner
Date: Wed, 19 Nov 1997 13:44:55 -0500

Dirk,

The only reasons I can think of that a beginner should not have a top
line instrument are:

1. A young kid shouldn't be saddled with responsibility for a $2,000
instrument that needs gentle and careful handling when a $200 instrument
will serve him for awhile and not be as vulnerable to damage.

2. A beginner may decide not to continue in music or to switch to,
say, flugel horn, making the investment in a top of the line clarinet
regrettable.

3. Plastic clarinets are usually lighter, which is easier for young
children with small hands and not a lot of hand strength.

None of these reasons would appear to apply to you. Like you, I
recognize that I will never be a world class player, but I enjoy playing
and I figure I can use every technical advantage that a good instrument
in excellent condition has to offer. I'd say, if you have the desire
and the money, go ahead and get the clarinet of your dreams. I
personally don't believe that they "blow out" or wear out, so I think
you'll be making a once in a lifetime investment. I have an R-13 B flat
and an R-13 A, and I don't expect ever to replace them, just to keep
them in good playing order. I don't think there's anything to be gained
by playing on an inferior instrument. Just my humble opinion. Good
luck making your selection, and enjoy it!

Nancy