Klarinet Archive - Posting 000210.txt from 1996/08

From: niethamer@-----.EDU
Subj: Re: Reed Trimmer
Date: Thu, 8 Aug 1996 02:43:14 -0400

On Sun, 4 Aug 1996, Cadenza wrote:

> Although the Cordier has for years been the best the relatively new Vandoren
> reed trimmer doesn't seem to "pull" the cane (therefore causing damage to the
> fibers) as much as the Cordier. Yes its expensive, and not easy to see how
> much of the reed you are trimming, but the end result is better. However, I
> don't think I've ever played a trimmed reed that was all that great, you still
> have to work on it.
>
> I would love to hear someother input about the Vandoren trimmer. Comments??
>
As a clarinetist who makes his own reeds, I have to advise throwing out
any brand of reed "crushers", expensive or cheap. Most reed
trimmers/clippers dull very quickly, if they ever *were* sharp, and crush
the fibers of the reed, with a noticable difference in the sound and
response of the reed as a result.

I form my own reed tip with either 400 or 600 wet/dry sandpaper, working
carefully toward the center of the reed from the corners. Since I've seen
double reed players form their reed tip (which is straight) with a sharp
knife, I'd suggest the following. "Clip" the requisite amount from the
very tip of the reed with your well-sharpened reed knife (which should
cut the fibers, not crush them). Then use sandpaper as above to carefully
re-form the tip to fit the rails of your mpc. The more carefully you
match the external shape of the rails, the "smoother" the response and
sound of the reed will be.

David Niethamer